Graphite: A Diamond In The Rough For Investors?

by Jack Lifton on January 1, 2011 · 25 comments

in Batteries, Graphite, Hybrids & EVs

Bookmark and Share Print

Today I want to look at China’s dominance of critical raw materials for clean-tech. Most people think that they left graphite behind when they graduated from pencils to pens early on in their school days, but the truth is that this slippery substance remains a crucial part of our daily lives. Consider the laptop computer, which has by and large replaced pens for most of us over the past decade — did you know that there is actually 10 times more graphite than lithium inside a lithium-ion battery?

Graphite has long been a key ingredient in steel, castings, lubricants, vehicle brakes, golf clubs, tennis rackets and — no surprise — pencils. But this polymer of carbon — a chemically identical sibling of both diamonds and coal — will become increasingly important in coming years due to its chemical, electrical and thermal properties. Its ability to remain stable in ordinary corrosive environments, conduct electricity and resist heat allow it to serve as a key component in applications like the storage batteries and nuclear-electricity generation stations that will power us into the future.

Coal powered the Industrial Revolution; its chemical twin, graphite, will be of great value in constructing the components of the clean-energy economy, making graphite a true diamond in the rough!

While one may assume that it is as common as the dirt that it somewhat resembles, the supply of graphite is far from infinite. Natural graphite comes in several forms: Flake, amorphous and lump. Of the one million tons of graphite that are processed each year, just 40% is of the most desirable flake type. Only flake and synthetic graphite (made through an expensive process from petroleum coke) can be used in lithium-ion batteries. Graphite mining and processing are limited to a relatively small handful of countries, with China currently producing 70% of the total global supply.

Demand for lithium-ion batteries will increase rapidly as battery-power (electricity) supplements, and will even replace gasoline- and diesel-fueled internal-combustion engines in vehicles as ‘green energy’ expands. While hybrid automobiles such as the Toyota Prius have used nickel-metal-hydride batteries for more than a decade, newer hybrid models like the Chevy Volt, as well as battery-only electric-drive vehicles like the Tesla Roadster and the Nissan Leaf, rely upon the more-efficient lithium-ion batteries that will almost certainly be employed in all hybrid or fully electric vehicles in just a few short years. Large-flake graphite will be very much in demand to produce the hundreds of millions of lithium-ion batteries required for these automobiles.

Governmental bodies are taking notice of just how crucial secure supplies of graphite are. Graphite prices have been increasing in recent months, and investors’ interest in this industry is almost certain to climb as word spreads about the impending boom in demand and the companies that will be making moves to meet it.

A Slippery Supply

Global graphite production has held steady at approximately one million tons per year over the past decade. The weak demand in the first half of the 2000s, combined with relatively low prices, led to little investment and development of graphite mining and processing capabilities over this time span. Many graphite-producing countries saw a steady drop in annual production between 2001 and 2008, including the Czech Republic, Russia, Madagascar, Zimbabwe, Canada and Mexico. Taking up the slack over this period were the Ukraine, Brazil, India and North Korea. China saw some peaks and valleys in production during this time, but currently produces nearly four-fifths of the world’s total supply of graphite, keeping 60% of this output for its own manufacturing requirements.

Japan, the U.S., Europe, South Korea and Taiwan — each of which has an economically significant and well-developed steel industry — import significant quantities of graphite from China. While China is the dominant player in the graphite game, 70% of its production is of the amorphous and lower-value small-flake graphite that is used in industrial applications rather than in batteries.

At this point in time, the fragmented nature and seasonality of its graphite production base raise some doubts that China will be able to increase its output; in fact, China itself currently imports a significant amount of North Korea’s graphite production. Producers in other regions of the world will need to step up their efforts to meet demand, which will require significant investment.

Increasing Applications Driving Demand

Graphite has long been a key component for the aviation, automotive, steel and plastic industries, as well as in the manufacture of bearings and lubricants. High-purity large-flake graphite is essential for the production of the lithium-ion batteries that are crucial to the consumer-electronics industry. Demand for this form of graphite will rise rapidly as production of larger batteries for vehicular propulsion comes online.

Currently, the iron and steel industries are the largest consumers of graphite. But demand for graphite has been rising for other applications — researchers in the field of material science continue to find new uses for this durable, heat-resistant, electricity-conducting substance. Graphite will be used in the construction of next-generation nuclear reactors, which are expected to reach temperatures as high as 1,000 °C in their cores — triple the temperature of today’s reactors.

Graphite is one of the few substances that can resist such heat. It has already replaced asbestos as a health-risk improvement in automotive brake linings and pads. As the standard of living rises in developing nations like Brazil, Russia, India and China, many more vehicles of all types will be added to the world’s roadways, increasing demand. Few people realize that 84% of the world’s total population lives in emerging-market countries.

Of course, it is expected that a rapidly growing number of automobiles will utilize extensive lithium-ion battery systems to assist with or singlehandedly provide propulsion, which is where the single-greatest increase in graphite demand is anticipated. At present, 2% of all new vehicles sold are gas-electric hybrids, plug-in hybrids or battery-only full-electric drive — most of which still use nickel-metal hydride batteries. It is projected that by 2020, these types of automobiles will represent 5-18% of all sales and almost exclusively be powered by lithium-ion batteries, which are both lighter and more powerful than nickel-metal hydride ones. With 70 million vehicles forecast to be sold in 2020, vast amounts of graphite will be required to manufacture the lithium-ion batteries that will power many of them.

Emerging fuel cell technologies also rely heavily on graphite. One of the more promising types under development, the proton-exchange-membrane fuel cell, requires 100 pounds of graphite per vehicle. Fuel cells will also be used for stationary power generation, as utility providers seek to overcome the inherent inefficiencies around electricity transmission to remote locations.

Perhaps the single greatest testimony to graphite’s importance is the concern that governmental bodies have shown about its important role in security. A 2010 European Commission study regarding the criticality of 41 different materials to the European economy included graphite among the 14 materials high in both economic importance and supply risk. A recent WikiLeaks posting revealed that a list known as the Critical Foreign Dependencies Initiative developed by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and the State Department included graphite mines in China among those overseas sites that could damage American interests if terrorists were to disable them. The U.S. military will also increasingly rely on graphite for battery and fuel cell applications, as the armed forces lessen their dependence on petroleum.

Intriguing Prospects

Top Stock Pick

China Carbon Graphite Group, Inc. (CHGI.OB), through its affiliate Xingyong Carbon Co. Ltd., manufactures graphite electrodes, fine-grain graphite, high-purity graphite and other carbon-derived products at its Inner Mongolia facility. The company believes that it is the largest wholesale supplier of fine-grain graphite and high-purity graphite in China. The company reported dramatically higher sales and earnings for the quarter ending September 30, 2010.

Additionally, China Carbon Graphite has started building new forming and baking plants in order to meet the growing demand for high-purity (and higher gross margin) products in the global market. Construction of the new forming plant, which will produce large-size ultra-high-graphite electrodes as well as high-purity and fine-grain graphite, is slated to be completed by June 2011. The new baking plant will have 36 furnaces and include 30,000 tons of annual capacity, making it the largest baking plant in China’s graphite industry.

The company noted in its recently-filed 10-Q that steel plants in China have been upgrading their electric-arc furnace facilities, which has boosted demand for large-size ultra-high graphite electrodes, a unique and specialized product. China’s steel industry, far and away the world’s largest, is today rapidly evolving into an industry, like that of the U.S., where electric-arc furnaces requiring graphite electrodes in huge quantities will ultimately be the dominant type of steel furnace used. This is inevitable, as the Chinese steel industry begins to utilize not only imported scrap steel and iron but, soon, domestically produced scrap as well. Shortages have developed and are expected to continue. Earnings could rise materially once these new plants are brought online.

The company’s long-term strategy is to diversify and expand its product offering by manufacturing graphite that would be used as a reflector or moderator in nuclear reactors in China — a product that would have significantly higher profit margins than its current offerings. At present, there are 11 nuclear power plants in China, with 15 more plants currently under construction — and only one other manufacturer of nuclear graphite pure enough for use in these plants. The company works with Hunan University and Qinghua University to research and develop nuclear-grade graphite.

China Carbon Graphite has approximately 550 full-time employees and a market capitalization of $24 million, and the shares trade at just over a dollar. This price could easily triple once the company begins to sell nuclear-grade graphite.

While some investors are wary of investing in Chinese companies due to the risks and volatility in China’s economy, CHGI represents a compelling speculation in the rapidly expanding global graphite industry. It is reassuring to know that internationally-recognized accounting firm BDO is the company’s auditor of record.

Lower Risk Pick

GrafTech International Limited (GTI), based in Parma, Ohio, is another strong graphite stock pick. Founded in 1886, GrafTech is one of the world’s largest manufacturers and providers of high-quality synthetic and natural graphite and carbon-based products. It has four major product categories — graphite electrodes, refractory products, advanced graphite materials and natural graphite — that it manufactures in 11 facilities on four continents, with customers in about 65 countries.

This low-cost global producer has a reputation for product quality, value and service excellence. It is one of the world’s largest manufacturers and providers of advanced graphite and carbon materials for the transportation, solar, and oil and gas industries. Approximately 70% of the graphite electrodes that it sells are consumed in the EAF steel melting process, the steelmaking technology used by “mini-mills.” According to the company’s most recent annual report, it operates “one of the world’s most technologically sophisticated advanced natural graphite production lines.”

The company’s share price has been hovering near $20 recently, and the current market capitalization is $2.4 billion. The stock is very heavily held by institutions such as The Vanguard Group, William Blair & Co. and Calamos Advisors. GrafTech appears to be very well positioned to fully capitalize on the favorable outlook for the graphite industry and the recovering global economy. Indeed, several analysts are projecting robust long-term sales and earnings growth for GrafTech.

Quality Speculation

Northern Graphite Corporation (not yet trading) is a mineral exploration and development company based in Ontario, Canada, that holds a 100% interest in mining claims for the Bissett Creek Project. The Bissett Creek Project consists of approximately 1,343 hectares near Mattawa, Ontario, that contain large crystal graphite flakes in a graphitic gneiss deposit.

The company is about to complete a multimillion-dollar public offering of common stock, and plans to use the proceeds to conduct metallurgical testing, prepare a pre-feasibility project report, and continue drilling and bulk sampling onsite. This project is unique in that almost 90% of the anticipated production is expected to be large-flake, very high-purity graphite that should command a premium price on the market.

Moreover, the company’s prospectus indicates that the mine’s assumed life should exceed 40 years, making Bissett Creek the only significant North American high-purity graphite producer. The deposit is near surface and only 10% of the property has been drilled to date. The project is ideally situated near the Trans-Canada Highway, with rail and power lines close by. Major graphite users in the steel and automotive sectors are in close proximity. These shares could quickly climb from the $0.50 IPO offering price once it begins trading in January 2011.

The Drive Is On

Graphite is one of the quintessential wonder materials of today that will only become more important moving forward. While the supply has proven adequate over the past decade, demand will increase significantly across all sectors of the industry in the years ahead. Already, prices are on the rise, with the best quality large-flake graphite rising in price from a low of $1,350/t to more than $2,000/t during the fourth quarter of 2010 alone. New supply sources will be needed to meet this uptick in demand — existing mining, processing companies and startups alike will require investment. The prudent investor will not want to miss out on this overlooked opportunity. The demand for metals and minerals is now fed by the insatiable economies of southeast Asia and Brazil. There is a lag between increasing supply and demand that leads to long-term price growth for producers of such natural resources.

Natural graphite price indications (crystalline, CIF European port, FCL, $/t)
rose rapidly in October 2010.
Grade 10/18/10 10/28/10
Fine: 90%C, -100 mesh, FCL 800-1,050 850-1,100
Fine: 94-97%C, -100 mesh, FCL 900-1,250 1,100-1,400
Medium flake: 85-87%C, +100 mesh – 80 mesh, FCL 900-1,100 950-1,200
Medium flake: 94-97% C, +100 mesh – 80 mesh, FCL 1,150-1,600 1,300-1,700
Large flake: 94-97% C, +80 mesh, FCL 1,350-2,000 1,400-2,000

Disclosure: I have no positions in any of the stocks mentioned above.

Bookmark and Share Print
1 fred cohen January 1, 2011 at 7:55 pm

Great article. Thanks.

2 Tom Emswiler January 1, 2011 at 8:20 pm

Thanks for such a fine article. I learned more about graphite in the few minutes it took to read the article than I had known for all my life. It sounds like this is an excellent investment opportunity.

3 Neal menaged January 1, 2011 at 9:32 pm

Very informative. How would you buy these recommendations. Buy the 2 companies plus the ipo when it comes out or, do you have a better way to do it. What % of each if I bought all 3?
Thank you.
Neal Menaged

4 Peter Plange January 1, 2011 at 10:27 pm

Excellent Report. Have an Australian Company “Strateqic Energy Resources” in my Watchlist. Co. has a project in South Australia “Uley”
25-150 Mt@6-9% total Carbon. Have taken on a North American JV
Partner.

5 Daniel Vasquez January 1, 2011 at 11:20 pm

Thanks Jack for another excellent article. Your writing is clear, concise and I always learn something new, prompting some research on my own.

GTI is the safe play, but I would imagine that a “basket” of the named stocks stocks would be the way to go.

6 Daniel Vasquez January 1, 2011 at 11:32 pm

BTW, I heard your recent web interview with Jim Puplava on his Financial News Hour program. Excellent. You didn’t mention any specific companies, but I bought a good long term position in SCCO as a result. Thanks again, Jack.

I’m newly retired to Mexico with a modest portfolio and I’m an energy and natural resources bull. I like that you give a variety risk companies for the investors considerations.

7 Kurt January 2, 2011 at 3:06 am

“But this polymer of carbon — a chemically identical sibling of both diamonds and coal — will become increasingly important in coming years due to its chemical, electrical and thermal properties.”

Both diamond an graphite are composed of elemental carbon with differing molecular arrangements. However, to say graphite is a polymer of carbon would not be correct.

8 Ph D Arnoldus M van den Hurk January 2, 2011 at 3:46 am

Congratularions for this fantastic article and very interesting comments.

I am a geologist with 8 years of experience in the solar energy industry.

Graphite is laso used in Solar Silicon Production in rods for Silicon purification, as catalizer for monocrystalline Silicon production for waters and as a part for crucibles in mono and policrystaline Silicon production.

Graphite and high purity Quartz are two “hidden” strategical Minerals in the CleanTech XXI century society.

9 RFw January 2, 2011 at 4:22 am

A very interesting report, thank you !

10 Ruediger Haberland January 2, 2011 at 4:43 am

Really great article! Thanks a lot.
I would be cautious about the rising demand in batteries for electrified cars as I assume that the prize and the weight and the lifetime of batteries will not be competitive for minimum 5 to 10 coming years – maybe never.
I would also be cautious about nuclear reactors of the future using a lot of graphite in high temperature environment.
There was a test with a high temperature reactor ingermany in the 70ies (THTR300) with the fuel-particles protected by pyrolitic carbon and encapsulated into 3″ graphite balls. A heap of these balls was the reactor core, cooled by Helium. Power was 300MW. A ridiculous construction of big-sized control rods that were pushed from above into the ball-heap resulted in early failure of the complete system by breaking into pieces the fuel-balls.
Some knowers pretend that this was sabotage by the then existing water-reactors producers (if so then in an early stage of planning).
(Pushing from below would produce nearly no damage to the balls.)
So wait and see.
My favorite is the AECL reactor that can burn much worse fuel than the today existing reactors and is able to burn most of its waste! And is inherently safe by using a small amount of heavy water as moderator and a large amount of ordinary water for cooling.

Remaining question: good quality synthetic graphite is in price how much higher if compared to same quality natural graphite?
Energy demand for graphitisation should go down considerably if oven (autoclave) size is upscaled. (Same development did revolutionise the quartz crystal growth).

Thank you once more and best wishes for 2011
RH

11 victor odubah January 2, 2011 at 7:58 am

Ph D Arnoldus M van den Hurk, Did you mean quartz with piezo-electrical properties suitable for incorporation into wireless equipment as frequency controllers? If yes, can it compete with artificially grown quartz crystals. Regards and best wishes in 2011

12 Marilyn January 2, 2011 at 8:24 am

Thank you Jack! This article is superb. No doubt it will prompt some healthy discussion which is what you probably intended in the first place.
The timing is perfect as resource investors evaluate the different options out there…uranium, vanadium, lithium, copper, etc.
Much appreciated. Happy New Year.

13 Clifford January 2, 2011 at 2:26 pm

Jack, to better serve your subscribers I think your articles should first be offered here, on this site. I read your Graphite article on Seeking Alpha before it was posted here. With your level of expertise and analysis the sequencing of publication could have a material effect on investors.

14 Cliff G January 2, 2011 at 2:48 pm

Thanks Jack for this truly informative article on investing in graphite for future demands…There is a junior company listed on the Vancouver venture exchange called Focus Metals Inc (FMS). This may very well be what all investors are looking for.Flake graphite deposit in Lac Knife Quebec.Just getting started and heading for much much higher prices in the future.Also has a REE property that looks very promising.Happy New Year to all.

15 alex January 2, 2011 at 3:36 pm

jack-funny thing ,just sold my shares in fms recently to take more positions in ruu, have looked at graphite for over a year thanks to you, my research also has come up with Northern Graphite and which also has a plant in Kearney,Ontario to reopen soon and owned 55% by IDSM ,industrial minerals, please tell me how this plays out for both and why not invest in idsm or are they now northern graphite, is there not a mine in KEARNEY

16 Durocher January 3, 2011 at 12:44 am

Jack – Excellent article. With all the focus put on REE and Li since the last year, the strategic importantce of graphite was missed by many “experts”.
Regarding FMS – From discussions I had at the last mining conference in Quebec City, Lac Knife deposit is of high quality and made of large flakes, production in the short is questionable.

17 Tek January 3, 2011 at 11:12 am

HMMMMmmmmm. China produces 80% of world supply. There are only a few other players and they’re rather small. Nobody is watching this sector..
THAT sounds familiar. Could be the commodities play of 2011?

18 Todd M January 3, 2011 at 7:15 pm

Thanks to this board for sharing their knowledge concerning flake graphite “GOLD”. I came across this article written by Lifton and believe this is the sleeping giant just awakening.
In this new technilogical age along with rare earth metals, I must agree that Focus Metals sounds like the place to be especially due to it’s size and geology. Once they uncover exactly what they have at Lac Knife I believe this story will be gigantic. As demand outstrips supply for these new precious metals and as Focus Metals moves foreward I believe this little gem will explode.
Remember the Dot Com’s…Mark my words. Thank you for the insight and heads up and all the very best in the coming New Year.

19 persistentone January 4, 2011 at 4:44 pm

Can someone explain why CHGI increased sales by $6M last quarter, but at the same time increased accounts receivable by $17M? The sales and earnings improvements here all seem to be coming at the cost of a worsening balance sheet.

20 DD January 7, 2011 at 2:46 pm

Be careful when investing in new graphite properties. Over the years, as China has driven up the price of graphite, older deposits are revisted and brought on line. Only to find that China will drive the price down to eliminate competition. It has happened in the past and will happen again. People need to remember that the deposits have been around, and looked at, for a long time.There are reasons why they were never fully developed in the past. These need to be fully studied prior to investment.

21 Ray January 9, 2011 at 4:40 pm

I’ve only just discovered your wonderful site and have spent several hours reading up on rare earths. Congratulations and many thanks.

However, on graphite you may have missed an important development. About 3 years ago Dr.Yi Cui of Stamford invented a silicon nano wire anode for the Li ion battery. It’s all in Wikipedia (search Nanowire battery) with links to the original publications. This could give up to 10x battery capacity. They hope to have a prototype for small applications (phones etc) this year but the real win would be electric cars. It’s not an entirely clear road (battery life etc) but if they can overcome or evade the problems this would be a huge game changer.

I’d love to get a slice of his start-up if such a company exists.

Ray

22 I DiStefano January 16, 2011 at 7:24 pm

i like to thank you for making me aware of the graphite story.I researched an australian co. asx. called ser. stratigic energy res. It is currently drilling at the moment but already on two holes have intersected significant resourse.From the time i read about graghite its share price has risen from .097 cents to currently .16 cents in a matter of 15 days trading.

23 stephen August 16, 2011 at 1:16 am

Thank you for the great article. Please advise if it is possible to have some new products by using graphite such as sim card for phone and computer. Thanks.

Best regards,
Stephen

24 george December 29, 2011 at 7:32 am

Great article.

25 Sarb Sekhon January 22, 2012 at 12:59 am

I am a shareholder of Lomiko Metals a company that trades on the Canadian venture exchange LMr and in the USA under LMRMF. IS there room for more graphite companies to do what NGC and FMS did in the way of performance last year? Many people are noticing graphite now.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: